Cat-back : which, why & thanks

Which cat-back?


  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .
I've trolled the forums a little bit to get a sense of the atmosphere in here and so far everyone seems to have good input :cool:
Please take it easy on me, I'm the new kid at school :)

I have a clean LX 5.0, 5spd car I'm building piece by piece.
The car has some minor bolt ons and 3.55's in the pumpkin.
For Christmas I got FRPP ceramic shorties and a Pypes 2.5" o/r X.
Now I need to buy a cat-back.

Which of these 2 should I get and why do you feel this way?
 
Go with magnaflow over Edelbrock. There are other options though that you might want to consider.
MAC
Flowmaster
Bassani
Spintech
Search for a link for a site that has all exhaust clips and see the one you like best.
 
IntenseBlue said:
:shrug:

That's not really a good reason to vote for it, but oh well.

Maybe, but I didn't see a reason why you feel the MagnaFlow is greater either, but oh well.

There isn't enough Edelbrock cat-back info out for anyone to make a definitive answer also, it seems. I know the MF cb is nice, but the I don't like the look of gaudy tips, and I don't know how they'll look on my coupe :shrug:
 
Magnaflow is stainless steel, they're the 2nd highest flowing street muffler on the market that I know of. They have the most wonderful tone I've ever heard. They're quiet at idle and the tone progressively becomes more agressive with rpm when daily cruising. All hell breaks lose when you romp on the car as far as sound goes. They're highly respected in the exhaust industry. One of the leaders. Last, they have a lifetime warranty.
 
i have the edelbrock with shorty headers, o/r x-pipe, and the edel cat back. it sounds good, has the better looking(imo) 2.5" tips, and the fit is very good.

all in all, you will be hard pressed to tell a diff in tone between the two. argue all you want, but both are glass packed muffs and have roughly the same size case.

i like magnaflows, don't get me wrong, but the size of thier tips is over the top for me.
 
You sure? Last I read they were 3 chamber, non packed mufflers, whereas the Magnaflows are a straight-through design with stainless steel packing which never burns out, unlike fiberglass, which is used in most other, if not all other straight-though muffler designs. I did my homework on exhaust systems before I purchased mine.
 
IntenseBlue said:
You sure? Last I read they were 3 chamber, non packed mufflers, whereas the Magnaflows are a straight-through design with stainless steel packing which never burns out, unlike fiberglass, which is used in most other, if not all other straight-though muffler designs. I did my homework on exhaust systems before I purchased mine.
100 percent sure.
 
sdt_main.jpg


This is Edelbrock's current muffler design and the one issued in their catback systems.
 
Go Bassani and you'll never look back.

If not go Magnaflow, theres probably a reason no one has Edlebrock. Im sure their good mufflers, but I doubt its anything special. Like said before Magnaflow is known for beautiful tame tone, and when you hit the pedal, it just explodes.
 
IntenseBlue said:
For the extra $250, I don't think that it's worth the price over the Magnaflow. Price is in the eye of the beholder, though.

I will agree you are paying alot for the name, but you are getting a quality piece that will last longer then your car. And I have to say Bassani has the nicest sound, but thats just my opinion. Im probably going to be getting just the mufflers and welding them in, but I guess thats not an option for a coupe cause he wants the tips.