I like mechanical gauges instead of electrical, but electric gauges have come a long way and are fairly accurate. I like oil pressure, water temp, and tranny temp (for auto's only) for a simple 3 gauge set up, but you can substitute fuel reading instead if you wanted. Between volt & gas I'd rather know if I'm running low on gas, which you will need more than to see if your alty isn't charging.
If you go mechanical and decide the oil pressure is what you want, spend the cash and go w/braided line instead of the plastic or copper lines. It is real easy to route and less of a chance of a leak; I have yet to have a problem going that route in the last 10yrs since I switched from copper tubing.